An estimator is a recipe that turns data into a guess. To judge a recipe, repeat the study many times and look at the spread of its guesses: its sampling distribution. Each run draws a fresh sample of n values from a population we chose ourselves, so we know the truth (dashed gold line). Two competing recipes are compared: teal on top, pink below. The solid line in each panel is the average of its guesses: if it sits on the gold line, the recipe is unbiased.
Unbiased means right on average, not right every time. Among unbiased recipes, prefer the one with the smaller spread (standard error); in general compare the mean squared error, MSE = bias² + variance.